Take the 2-minute tour ×
Geographic Information Systems Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for cartographers, geographers and GIS professionals. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I am looking for an alternative software product for cartography other than ArcGIS and Adobe Illustrator. The graphic quality in ArcGIS outputs is substantially poor when compared to outputs in illustrator, yet illustrator is not a true cartographic software package. Any open source? Any extensions to ArcGIS or Illustrator that would enhance performance? Read a couple referrals to MAPublisher in other forums, yet this package is too expensive ($2000+). Thanks for any help you are able to provide.

share|improve this question

13 Answers 13

I've tried (not professionaly) MAPublisher. For what I could assess, it greatly improves the workflow for professional map design. I mean, truly professional.

Most people work with a GIS software and then export it to a graphics package. What Ian described is that you can work with any GIS software that exports to SVG and then import it in a design software, such as Illy, Corel Draw, Inkscape, etc.

The OS solution that I would recomend is that same as iant: QGIS + Inkscape. The two softwares together aren't as powerful as ArcGIS + Illustrator but you can create amazing maps with it.

edit oh and one ArcGIS extension that WILL improve quality and production is Maplex. It has a different labelling engine and it is fantastic. It can do amazing things for you, since it automagically places 90% of the labels for you, has great font/style control, etc.

share|improve this answer

QGIS can output as SVG which will allow you to edit it in Illustrator (or Inkscape).

share|improve this answer
3  
The SVG Print Composer for QGIS 1.6 has the fine print: "The SVG export function in Qgis has several problems due to bugs and deficiencies in the Qt4 svg code. In particular, there are problems with layers not being clipped to the map bounding box. If you require a vector-based output file from Qgis it is suggested that you try printing to PostScript if the SVG output is not satisfactory." –  Mike T Mar 20 '11 at 8:13

Probably not in the same league as ArcGIS and MAPublisher, but you could check out Maperitive. Currently it's oriented towards OpenStreetMap data, but I plan to add shapefile support in the near future (I'm the author BTW). It's not a full-blown GIS package, but the price is competitive ($0).

Since you were mentioning Illustrator: Maperitive has an export-svg command which generates SVGs specifically designed for Illustrator (and Inkscape).

share|improve this answer

Manifold GIS is a great option, it can do pretty much anything ArcGis can do, albiet sometimes you'll need to use spatial sql or some programming, and best of all, it's less than $500.

Edit: I was asked to provide some more details, so here goes. In general, I don't find the cartographic tools in Manifold parituclar intuitive, but if you take some time to read the lengthy and comprehensive documentation, you'll generally find what you need. There are some showcase maps from users on their website:

http://www.manifold.net/info/gallery.shtml

You can export to lots of image formats, or vector formats like pdf, adobe illustrator or kml. Also, I noticed that they actually do now offer a money back 10 day trial, so you can try it out more easily:

http://www.manifold.net/admin/refunds.shtml

Check out their site, or ask about it on their forum, you'll get responses quickly -

http://manifold.net/

http://www.georeference.org/forum/

share|improve this answer
1  
Welcome to GIS.se :) Please point out Manifold's cartographic attributes which make this an answer to the question, otherwise it reads like spam. I didn't downvote your answer, but I expect that's why someone else did. Unfortunately mentions of Manifold trigger this reaction more readily than other softwares do. In other venues Manifold users have tended to be rather...enthusiastic... in extolling Manifold's virtues and criticising others' shortcomings. So people are wary. –  matt wilkie Mar 20 '11 at 6:25
    
lol, had no idea people had already had experiences like that with Manifold, I work with both ArcGIS and Manifold, and can speak to eithers benefits and shortcomings. I'll edit the post a bit now, wasn't sure how many details to include- –  chrismarx Mar 22 '11 at 16:31

OCAD (not Free like QGIS) but does a good job cartographically

http://www.ocad.ch/en/index.htm

enter image description here

functionality PDF - Exports to Adobe Illustrator.

http://www.ocad.com/OCAD10/OCAD10_functionality_chart.pdf

share|improve this answer

Check out the CARIS software suite (www.caris.com). Utilised by many, if not most, of International Hydrographic Organisation (IHO) affiliated Hydrographic Offices. CARIS Composer and or CARIS GIS pro is probably what you're looking for. Not cheap though, but nor is ARC Map.

share|improve this answer

I think GVSig has the ability to export map to SVG file. You can then work on it with Inkscape. If not yet, it should be on the roadmap. At least, you would be able to process through PDF, as follow : http://listserv.gva.es/pipermail/gvsig_internacional/2010-November/006327.html

share|improve this answer

I posted a similar question on the CartoTalk forums, but recieved a similarly negative response. All of the above tools seem to be ways of exporting from GIS software to a graphics format, which is something I'm sure you already know how to do.

It would be very useful if someone coded a basic extension to Adobe Illustrator that provided the most useful part of MapPublisher - importing and georeferencing shapefiles - without all of the extra cartographic functionality.

share|improve this answer

Canvas with GIS+ ? Vector drawing software for cartography. Never used it, but it's definitely cheaper than MaPublisher.

http://store.acdsee.com/store/acd/en_US/DisplayProductDetailsPage/productID.219452200

share|improve this answer

Again not freeware or open source, but the online service indiemapper may be of interest. While it has a monthly service fee, they do have a 30 day free trial in which you can see if the maps their services produce are worth the price.

They have some maps I would consider really professional looking in their gallery, and it appears they have really good support for projections that are intended for visualizing the entire globe. They have also gotten some exposure on this forum previously for their value-by-alpha maps, which isn't an out of the box capability of ArcMap (as far as I'm aware).

Also a note I have no affiliation with indiemapper, they just produce quality stuff so that is why I suggest them as an alternative.

share|improve this answer

Not really a desktop solution but Mapnik (really high quality rendering) and Mapserver both enabled you to render SVG using cairo. So you generate your maps and like most others solutions you use Inkscape to finish the job.

share|improve this answer

Have you looked at avenza.
It pulls data from arcgis into illustrator

share|improve this answer
    
Sorry Brad, "Avenza" is "Avenza MAPublisher", which is the same package he already said was unacceptable. –  matt wilkie Mar 20 '11 at 6:22

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.