Take the 2-minute tour ×
Geographic Information Systems Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for cartographers, geographers and GIS professionals. It's 100% free, no registration required.

When I try to transform geometries from SRID 2321 to 4326, the transformed coordinates are swapping. Why is this happening?

Below are the details

Source

SRID - EPSG:2321

Source Data Projection Definition:

  • WGS84 Bounds: 31.5000, 35.9000, 34.5000, 42.1000
  • Projected Bounds:364573.0642, 3975550.1410, 635426.9358, 4663916.1654
  • Area: Turkey - 31.5°E to 34.5°E

below are the sample points :

  • 470343.6,4402310.3
  • 470105.0,4402410.8
  • 470236.5,4402700.1

Destination

SRID - EPSG:4326

Below are the sample points after conversion:

  • 32.6539666652,39.753664831
  • 32.6511781435,39.7545616174
  • 32.6526994043,39.7571716999

When I try to project these point on a Google map they are referencing to Iraq when they should refer to Turkey.

But when I tried with reversing the coordinates of the above points then they are referencing to correct locations on Google maps

Why is this happening? Do I miss anything?

EDIT:

Software used for conversion : Spatialite v 4.1.1 and this conversion is confirmed using this link.

Actually my source data is from ESRI personal geodatabase .mdb file. I used QGIS to import them into Spatialite and when I try to project them on google/Apple maps all data is referencing to a different location.

share|improve this question
    
What do you mean the coordinates are swapping? 32.6539666652,39.753664831 is actually 32.6539666652E,39.753664831N, which does fall in Turkey. I think you might be running into a confusion similar to this: gis.stackexchange.com/a/54066/442 –  Devdatta Tengshe Feb 7 at 3:08
add comment

1 Answer

up vote 5 down vote accepted

When talking about geographic locations, we usually say and use Lat-long. This has been codified in the ISO 6709 standard.

When dealing with Cartesian coordinate geometry, we generally use X-Y. Many GIS systems, work with a Geographic Location as a special case of a 2 D coordinate point, where the X represents the longitude and Y represents the Latitude. This order of coordinates, is exactly opposite that of the regular Lat-long notion.

SO when Spatialite gives 32.6539666652,39.753664831, it is actually 32.6539666652E,39.753664831N since the first coordinate is X (i.e longitude) & second one is Y (i.e. Latitude).

If you put just 32.6539666652,39.753664831 in Google Maps, it assumes that you are giving coordinates in Lat-Long, and not in XY. It parses the coordinates as: 32.6539666652N ,39.753664831E. That's why it shows you the point in Iraq

So I'll say that this isn't a bug, just a matter of confusing and contradictory standards.

For similar Issues, go through these two Q&A:

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.