Hot answers tagged arccatalog
I have 10.2, which version of ArcGIS do you have (you should always quote that)? Anyway just tested the tool against the arcpy method and both return the same value for me. Did you actually set the band number as you did in the arcpy method? The only thing I would suggest is to recompute the statistics, maybe they have become corrupted in same way?
Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible