Skip to main content
Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackGIS/status/627624690580881408
edited tags
Link
Removed signature etc as per help instructions; removed statement of urgency
Source Link
PolyGeo
  • 65.4k
  • 29
  • 114
  • 345

As a part of my PhD I have to map the rivers of Northern Peloponnese, Greece. I have downloaded two DEMs from Nasa Reverb, which I connected with "mosaic to new raster". I have started the usual process of "fill", "flow direction" and "flow accumulation" in order to be able to analyze the rivers of the area. But unfortunately I'm facing two problems.

First one is that the results I get from Flow Direction tool are wrong and I can't edit them, no matter what I try. As you can see at the screenshot, there are some horizontal flow lines that make no sense. I tried editing the values (tried to make arcmap exclude values lower than 1) of the original raster and then using "fill" but that doesn't prevent the "fill" tool from ignoring these areas.

Second problem (which seems to be connected to the first one) is that I decided to move to the next step and use "Flow Accumulation" anyway as some areas seemed to be fine and see what happens.

As you can see from the screenshot the flow accumulation lines follow the shoreline shape and then extend in the sea. As far as I can understand, these flow accumulation lines follow the flow direction ones so the problem is created when I use the "flow direction" tool.

Can you please help? I'm fairly new to this so excuse my ignorance, I'm really desperate as I'm stuck and I spent many hours trying to find a solution. If

If it's a problem with the original data and the problem can't be corrected, is there a way around it?

Many thanks George

flow direction screenshot

flow accumulation screenshot

As a part of my PhD I have to map the rivers of Northern Peloponnese, Greece. I have downloaded two DEMs from Nasa Reverb, which I connected with "mosaic to new raster". I have started the usual process of "fill", "flow direction" and "flow accumulation" in order to be able to analyze the rivers of the area. But unfortunately I'm facing two problems.

First one is that the results I get from Flow Direction tool are wrong and I can't edit them, no matter what I try. As you can see at the screenshot, there are some horizontal flow lines that make no sense. I tried editing the values (tried to make arcmap exclude values lower than 1) of the original raster and then using "fill" but that doesn't prevent the "fill" tool from ignoring these areas.

Second problem (which seems to be connected to the first one) is that I decided to move to the next step and use "Flow Accumulation" anyway as some areas seemed to be fine and see what happens.

As you can see from the screenshot the flow accumulation lines follow the shoreline shape and then extend in the sea. As far as I can understand, these flow accumulation lines follow the flow direction ones so the problem is created when I use the "flow direction" tool.

Can you please help? I'm fairly new to this so excuse my ignorance, I'm really desperate as I'm stuck and I spent many hours trying to find a solution. If it's a problem with the original data and the problem can't be corrected, is there a way around it?

Many thanks George

flow direction screenshot

flow accumulation screenshot

As a part of my PhD I have to map the rivers of Northern Peloponnese, Greece. I have downloaded two DEMs from Nasa Reverb, which I connected with "mosaic to new raster". I have started the usual process of "fill", "flow direction" and "flow accumulation" in order to be able to analyze the rivers of the area. But unfortunately I'm facing two problems.

First one is that the results I get from Flow Direction tool are wrong and I can't edit them, no matter what I try. As you can see at the screenshot, there are some horizontal flow lines that make no sense. I tried editing the values (tried to make arcmap exclude values lower than 1) of the original raster and then using "fill" but that doesn't prevent the "fill" tool from ignoring these areas.

Second problem (which seems to be connected to the first one) is that I decided to move to the next step and use "Flow Accumulation" anyway as some areas seemed to be fine and see what happens.

As you can see from the screenshot the flow accumulation lines follow the shoreline shape and then extend in the sea. As far as I can understand, these flow accumulation lines follow the flow direction ones so the problem is created when I use the "flow direction" tool.

Can you please help? I'm fairly new to this so excuse my ignorance.

If it's a problem with the original data and the problem can't be corrected, is there a way around it?

flow direction screenshot

flow accumulation screenshot

corrected tag, removed greeting
Source Link
Evil Genius
  • 6.3k
  • 2
  • 28
  • 40

George from Greece here and I start with (what else) a problem I'm facing. AsAs a part of my PhD I have to map the rivers of Northern Peloponnese, Greece. I have downloaded two DEMs from Nasa Reverb, which I connected with "mosaic to new raster". I have started the usual process of "fill", "flow direction" and "flow accumulation" in order to be able to analyze the rivers of the area. But unfortunately I'm facing two problems.

First one is that the results I get from Flow Direction tool are wrong and I can't edit them, no matter what I try. As you can see at the screenshot, there are some horizontal flow lines that make no sense. I tried editing the values (tried to make arcmap exclude values lower than 1) of the original raster and then using "fill" but that doesn't prevent the "fill" tool from ignoring these areas.

Second problem (which seems to be connected to the first one) is that I decided to move to the next step and use "Flow Accumulation" anyway as some areas seemed to be fine and see what happens.

As you can see from the screenshot the flow accumulation lines follow the shoreline shape and then extend in the sea. As far as I can understand, these flow accumulation lines follow the flow direction ones so the problem is created when I use the "flow direction" tool.

Can you please help? I'm fairly new to this so excuse my ignorance, I'm really desperate as I'm stuck and I spent many hours trying to find a solution. If it's a problem with the original data and the problem can't be corrected, is there a way around it?

Many thanks George

flow direction screenshot

flow accumulation screenshot

George from Greece here and I start with (what else) a problem I'm facing. As a part of my PhD I have to map the rivers of Northern Peloponnese, Greece. I have downloaded two DEMs from Nasa Reverb, which I connected with "mosaic to new raster". I have started the usual process of "fill", "flow direction" and "flow accumulation" in order to be able to analyze the rivers of the area. But unfortunately I'm facing two problems.

First one is that the results I get from Flow Direction tool are wrong and I can't edit them, no matter what I try. As you can see at the screenshot, there are some horizontal flow lines that make no sense. I tried editing the values (tried to make arcmap exclude values lower than 1) of the original raster and then using "fill" but that doesn't prevent the "fill" tool from ignoring these areas.

Second problem (which seems to be connected to the first one) is that I decided to move to the next step and use "Flow Accumulation" anyway as some areas seemed to be fine and see what happens.

As you can see from the screenshot the flow accumulation lines follow the shoreline shape and then extend in the sea. As far as I can understand, these flow accumulation lines follow the flow direction ones so the problem is created when I use the "flow direction" tool.

Can you please help? I'm fairly new to this so excuse my ignorance, I'm really desperate as I'm stuck and I spent many hours trying to find a solution. If it's a problem with the original data and the problem can't be corrected, is there a way around it?

Many thanks George

flow direction screenshot

flow accumulation screenshot

As a part of my PhD I have to map the rivers of Northern Peloponnese, Greece. I have downloaded two DEMs from Nasa Reverb, which I connected with "mosaic to new raster". I have started the usual process of "fill", "flow direction" and "flow accumulation" in order to be able to analyze the rivers of the area. But unfortunately I'm facing two problems.

First one is that the results I get from Flow Direction tool are wrong and I can't edit them, no matter what I try. As you can see at the screenshot, there are some horizontal flow lines that make no sense. I tried editing the values (tried to make arcmap exclude values lower than 1) of the original raster and then using "fill" but that doesn't prevent the "fill" tool from ignoring these areas.

Second problem (which seems to be connected to the first one) is that I decided to move to the next step and use "Flow Accumulation" anyway as some areas seemed to be fine and see what happens.

As you can see from the screenshot the flow accumulation lines follow the shoreline shape and then extend in the sea. As far as I can understand, these flow accumulation lines follow the flow direction ones so the problem is created when I use the "flow direction" tool.

Can you please help? I'm fairly new to this so excuse my ignorance, I'm really desperate as I'm stuck and I spent many hours trying to find a solution. If it's a problem with the original data and the problem can't be corrected, is there a way around it?

Many thanks George

flow direction screenshot

flow accumulation screenshot

Source Link
Loading