FME Desktop saves Transformers uncommented in Workspace File

Question

I'm using FME Desktop 2014 SP1 to create a rather huge mapping process from ArcSDE Feature classes to INSPIRE GML Writer. After saving the Workspace and reopening it a couple of days later, all Transformers and also some readers were gone.

I opened the workspace file with notepad++ where I could recognize some of the disappeared transformers information, but it was commented out with #

I also tried to save the workspace under different names, but every time the same happened.

I think it should be possible to recover the transformers by manually deleting '#'s but that's no suitable solution to keep on working on my workbench.

Had anybody issues like these or knows a solution to this?

Answer 1

Did you upgrade your FME in the time between editings? I recently had a 2014 workspace that, when I opened it in 2015, all I got was an empty canvas. It turned out to be some characters in annotation objects that could not be parsed (not sure the exact reason).

Anyway, as Jonathan says, send it to our support team and we will get the developer to take a look at it. I am sure it can be fixed... as long as you haven't made any manual edits. You definitely don't want to start editing fmw files by hand.

For the record, the upper "half" of an fmw file is XML(ish) that defines the workspace in Workbench; i.e. what objects are where on the canvas and how they are connected, etc.

The lower half of an fmw file is Mapping File code. This is the part used by the FME engine when the workspace is run. Every time you edit the workspace in Workbench, both parts get updated.

So you'll see that it's not easy at all to manually edit the file. If you make changes to the upper half only it won't affect how the workspace is run, and if you make changes to the lower half only then it won't affect how the workspace is depicted - plus the lower part gets entirely regenerated as soon as you open the file in Workbench and make a change.

Basically it's not practical to make manual edits to the file contents. If you ever think your file has been corrupted like this, please do send it to our support team asap and we'll probably be able to figure out how to fix it.

Answer 2

Trying to manually parse and alter the .fmw files is almost certailing a losing proposition.

Lines starting #! in a FMW workspace aren't necessarily a comment. As you've figured out, they are a comment within TCL (the language of a .fmw file), however you'll see that actually almost all the lines that start #! actually look like XML. I believe that FMW files contain a combination TCL, and commented-out XML within that and that this is intentional.

Looking at several of my workspaces, the first 4/5ths of the file are consistently of this #! XML structure.

The last line of this XML section is: #! </WORKSPACE> after which normal TCL starts, and anything commented out there is likely an actual comment.

I'd suggest it's worth emailing your support and having them look into it; it may be a bug. May also be worth upgrading to a newer version of FME.