2

Can someone explain what is the history of BING vs. HERE maps and what are the differences as of today (2015 Q4)?

I'd be especially interested in the Satellite view, as BING maps was one of the providers which allowed OSM referencing. Does HERE maps allow such thing now that they are separate?

5

I'm on the Bing Maps team and have worked closely with HERE for many years.

Bing Maps uses a number of different data providers for different types of data. Most of the road data comes from NAVTEQ (now owned by Nokia HERE) and has been the primary data provider for Bing Maps since 2005 I believe. In certain countries other data providers are used. Most notable are China (AutoNavi), South Korea (SK Planet), Japan (Zenrin). TomTom is used for some data types such as Postal Code boundaries, but I don't believe their road data is used. Ordnance Survey is used for Postal Code data in the UK.

The aerial/satellite imagery comes from a number of different sources. Most of the imagery in the US and Western Europe was captured by the Bing Maps team themselves using camera's that they built themselves (hired companies like Digital Globe to fly Microsoft camera's). The Bing Maps team actual bought a company many years ago called Vexcel who make some of the most widely used camera's for capturing aerial imagery. Digital Globe has been a data provider for Bing Maps for a long time as well. Satellite imagery is also sourced from NASA. Birdseye imagery comes from Pictometry and Blom.

As for comparing Bing Maps to HERE, Bing Maps combines a bunch of premium data sources together including data from HERE to provide a best in class set of data set. HERE does have some benefits in that they do have some older NAVTEQ services that provide some more in-depth functionality that most Bing Maps users don't need, such as Truck based routing. That said, being that HERE is one of the main data providers for Bing Maps, you can license these in-depth services on their own from HERE and use them with Bing Maps. I actually have a number of customers who are doing this as they prefer the imagery, data and services available in Bing Maps which is what they need for majority of their use cases and they also like the enterprise level support that all licensed customer have access to at no additional cost.

  • Bing Maps provides truck routing and many other new services which HERE had that Bing didn't such as distance matrix, isochrones and snap to road API's. – rbrundritt Nov 10 '17 at 18:58
1

My experience with HERE data is that it is not as updated as either BING, or GARMIN or APPLE. Case in point, I have a 2015 car with GPS that did not have data on a new home development (built in 2013). I just paid for a 2017 update - and the HERE data file still does not include those houses, or addresses. My Garmin NUVI 3790 does have those houses and addresses. Interestingly, the GARMIN unit gets updates annually at no extra cost - the car GPS was over $180 to get what is an outdated data set. Not a very honest thing to do. I have written to HERE, but so far they simply ignore the error and have kept my money.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.