I have GCS shapefiles that I loaded back into an SDE state plane database. The database shows that they are in State Plane, not GCS. Are they actually in the correct state plane or are they still in GCS and will be distorted or shifted in some small way?

  • If you stored them in a database that is state plane, why do you think they would be anything other than state plane? – BradHards Sep 20 '16 at 22:02
  • It's impossible to tell, since you haven't provided layer metadata. Note that ArcSDE is not a database (it doesn't even exist anymore), so editing the question to specify the actual database in use and versions of all software might shed light on how we could help. – Vince Sep 21 '16 at 1:22

jbalk's answer is the means to intentionally convert from your GCS to State Plane.

The direct answer to your question is that unless you intentionally changed/transformed the projection into State Plane the data is probably still in GCS but stored 'thinking' it is in State Plane. At that point, a feature at lat long 30,90 will be showing close to 0,0 in the State Plane projection.

You can set the coordinate system for a file without it really being projected into that coordinate system.


ArcGIS answer

  • Copy the original shapefile.
  • Use the Project Tool to convert to the state plane zone.
  • Load it into the database.

Open ArcMap and add the two layers from the ArcSDE database.

They should line up because ArcMap will have set the data frame's coordinate system to one of the layers, and the other layer will be projected on-the-fly to the data frame's coordinate system.

  • Open data frame properties and select the Coordinate System tab.
  • Click the globe button and select Clear.

enter image description here

If they're in coordinate systems as different as a geographic (lat-lon) one and a state plane one, they won't overlay anymore.

Similary, look at the extents of both layers. The original data will have extents in decimal degrees, while the state plane layer should have much larger coordinate values (in meters or feet (US or international)).

  • This is mostly a test of project-on-the-fly capability, not necessarily whether the data is in a specific coordinate reference. – Vince Sep 21 '16 at 11:20
  • I'm going to edit your answer into an ArcGIS one. Feel free to revert/reword/whatever. – mkennedy Sep 21 '16 at 17:38

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.