1

I would like to combine the workflow of fuzzy membership and weighted overlay for a suitability analysis and would like to ask if this is "allowed" scientifically.

I have severeal criteria, some would first use Fuzzy Membership to get a membership value from 0-1, some other criteria do not use Fuzzy Membership before (they get a Value from 0-10 through another method).

Then I would standardize the fuzzy value...multiply it with 10, that all criteria have values from 0-10.

After that I wouldn't use "Fuzzy Overlay", but I would use "Weighted Sum" and weight all criteria.

Now my question is: Is this "allowed" to combine Fuzzy membership and Weighted Overlay, or do I have to use "fuzzy overlay" when I work with fuzzy memberships? I would use "Fuzzy Membership" just for the standardization.

2

That I believe your approach is completely valid. You are using a function to assign suitability values, the fact that the function is implemented in Fuzzy Membership tool does not mean that you can not use it in another context.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.