3

I'm in the midst of aligning century-old maps (of Paris) to vector data of the modern same: Qgis' Georeferencer tool works fine, but doing the entire city that way is a gargantuan task. Paris hasn't changed much over the past century, and there is some lens distortion at the edges of the photo of a paper map that is torn in some places, but in all, the raster maps match the present city layout (vector) to ~85%.

I was wondering if anyone has heard of a tool or method that can match 'detected lines' in raster to vector coordinates... I can imagine a first step would be to 'rough align' the maps to vector using Georeferencer, but it's the 'fine tuning' that is most problematic and time-consuming.

vector data in bright red; this is the post-alignment result.

  • I think that depending on your goal there must be many ways to do the job. I guess that what you want is to see some raster data over you polygones. Did you try to interpolate your raster to a very small resolution and then use rater to polygone, etc ? – César Arquero Nov 20 '17 at 11:25
0

I am facing the same problem.

For fine tuning, try adding more points where the image is distorted. I also found the Setting the Transformation type in QGIS to 'Thin Plate Spline' improves the result. Also, adding more points near where the distortions occur would help the mapping.

It may be possible to use the Register feature of Google Earth Engine. This will automatically warp and distort the overlay to align with an underlay. I am not sure if this will work on line drawings though. The trick would be to ensure the algorithm can detect the pixels that are supposed to match. Register might work if you aligned the raster with a modern map with similar lines. I haven't tried it yet.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.