0

Followed instructions from various posts (each one with slight variations on the theme) and most of the time have no trouble getting the installed GDAL to accept ECW files. However, QGIS refuses to accept the fact that GDAL is ECW-enabled and keeps telling me the format is not supported. As no one even mentions the fact that QGIS will NOT work even if GDAL itself does, I must be missing something really obvious somewhere (like the need to compile QGIS from source).

How to otherwise get ECW in the list of supported raster files in the qgis settings menu?

System info:

  • Virtual machines using VMWare workstation 7 on Win7 Pro.
  • LinuxMint12 (Ubuntu 11 Oneiric) with QGIS 1.7.4 upgraded to QGIS 1.8.0 and GDAL 1.9
  • Clean LinuxMint 13 (Ubuntu 12 Precise) with QGIS 1.8 and GDAL 1.9 as installed from qgis package

In all cases gdalinfo --formats list ECW as supported and commandline gdal_translate and gdalwarp work fine with ECW as input and output (translate only), but QGIS knows better and refuses to even try.

Improve this question
1
  • Are you sure that the GDAL you are using in QGIS is the same GDAL you are testing on the command line? How did you get GDAL with ECW support?
    – BradHards
    Aug 4, 2012 at 22:42

2 Answers 2

Reset to default
4

Sorry for late reply, had to get time free to sort it out from a brand new setup. Found out what is causing it and it has nothing to do with using the correct gdal as suggested in Answer 1 (I did run into it before as automatic updates on linux will happily upgrade the qgis-installed GDAL to 1.9.1-2~precise4 and you get that version-mismatch error).

A fresh install of QGIS 1.8.0 on a new linux mint 13 (ubuntu 12.04 precise) installs GDAL 1.7.3-6ububtu3 and that is the one against which the ECW support gets compiled. I did exactly the same as listed in my original post, and as expected the qgis-installed gdal 1.7 does support ECW while QGIS does not. Back to square one...

However, in the course of digging through tons of website pages, I did come across a post somewhere (lost which one, though) that mentions that from gdal 1.8 the location of the pluginsdirectory has changed from gdalXXplugins to gdalplugins/1.8. As QGIS 1.8.0 actually uses GDAL 1.7.3-6ubuntu3 under the hood I had ignored that info. Unfortunately, this information is not correct!! GDAL 1.7.3 also needs to have the plugin stored in the gdalplugins/1.7 folder! This is not done by the scripts so you have to do it manually. I did it by using prefixes on my last install, but it is as easy to just create the /usr/lib/gdalplugins/1.7 folder by hand and copy/move the so file from the /usr/lib/gdal17plugins folder. Done. Now QGIS 1.8.0 finds the plugin and loads ECW fine.

Hope this helps others in the same situation. Not to mention the fact that one must find the correct gdal ecw source! The 1.7.2 source is only found when you edit the repo by hand to use the old "hardy" version. If only qgis.org could keep that one file in its repo too... Sigh. Lewie

Improve this answer
2

The above comment is the right interpretation of the issue: you added support for ECWs to a copy of GDAL that is not the one used by QGIS (you can check what GDAL version is used by QGIS by opening the "about" dialog). Use the ubuntugis repository that ships with GDAL 1.9 and QGIS 1.8 compiled against the very same GDAL version.

Improve this answer

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.