I have partial bathymetric / topographic coverage at 1m resolution of a lake bed and shore and am trying to find an appropriate method for 'filling in the gaps'. I have tried using the following in ArcGIS:

  • IDW: weight = 1, number of points = 12, search radius = variable

I chose IDW weight of 1 because I understood that this would do a straight line interpolation between known points. However it seems that there is some form of distance limit (even though I chose variable radius, which means the end result is more like a Thiessen polygon (i.e. a step between horizontal extrapolations from known points)

I then tried a spline with following inputs:

  • Spline: type = regularized, weight = 0.1, number of points = 12.

This produced a similar break around the halfway point between the known data, suggesting some form of distance limit, but also introduced 'corrugations' on the shore side, which I assume are due to undulations at the lake shore being extrapolated and magnified.

Views are shown in the images below overlain with the original point data from combined topo/bathymetry (done in QGIS so I could use the Profile tool).

Options I have considered are:

  • fiddling around with spline parameters to see if changing these would produce a more realistic slope
  • Set a barrier just behind the lake shore and use the 'Spline with barriers' tool (perhaps with more points) to force the tool to interpolate across the full extent
  • Try and use the interpolation tools in QGIS (I previously got error message about k values when using IDW so used ArcGIS)
  • Use some publicly available data (e.g. ASTER / SRTM) to try and get some intermediate points and redo using IDW or spline

I don't know what the shape of the profile should be but would assume than a straight line interpolation or maybe an S-curve would be more realistic than a steep cliff which both methods are producing at the moment.

Just wondering if anyone out there has faced a similar problem and what worked for them?



Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.