I have a set of Polygons (in Shapely) that I wish to find all intersections that are comprised of overlaps of two or more polygons. I have been working based off the code found in this answer. I have a code so far that works in the if 1: statement below, but it takes a very long time to run. The code that is in the if 0: statement, runs quickly, but produces an output with some errors. See below for an example of the error.

from shapely.geometry import Point, LineString, shape, mapping
from shapely.ops import cascaded_union
import fiona
import shapely
from shapely.ops import unary_union, polygonize
from osgeo import ogr
from shapely.strtree import STRtree

with fiona.open("Untitled.shp") as layer:
   for n,pol in enumerate(subset):
      if type(shape(pol['geometry'])) == shapely.geometry.polygon.Polygon:
      elif type(shape(pol['geometry'])) == shapely.geometry.multipolygon.MultiPolygon:
         print('theres one here')
         for x in tmp:

   rings = [LineString(list(pol.exterior.coords)) for pol in spoof]
   union = unary_union(rings)

   tree = STRtree(spoof)
   result = [geom for geom in polygonize(union)]

   if 1:
      for k,item1 in enumerate(result):
         for n,item2 in enumerate(spoof):
            if item1.intersection(item2).area >1e-8:
         if count>=2:

   if 0:
      for k,item in enumerate(result):
         if len(touch)>=2:

Below, the orange represents all the shapes that I would like to check if they are produced (by unary union in Shapely) by two or more overlaps, the cyan represents the output of the if-statement that works (if 1 in above code), and the pink represents the incorrect selected polygons by the if-statement that doesn't work (if 0 in above code). The top left corners of the text boxes in the pictures represent that point being selected, and as you can see the second picture, the pink area only has one polygon from the STEREO_OBSERVATIONS (which is the set of polygons that are being checked for overlap) so it should not be selected. By contrast, the left adjacent cyan square to the pink square highlighted in the third picture has two polygons from STEREO_OBSERVATIONS and as such is correctly selected by the cyan result. The layering of the polygon layers is shown in the first picture.

What is the best way to query the STRtree structure so as to check to intersection or overlap? I have tried to use the centroid in the code, but that hasn't seemed to produce the correct output.

Fig. 1 (Legend/layering) enter image description here

Fig 2. (Incorrect selection by fast algorithm [if 0 in code] in pink) enter image description here

Fig 3. (Correct selection by slow algorithm [if 1 in code] enter image description here

  • I added the imports, what is the best way to share a simple dataset?
    – Loonuh
    Apr 11 '19 at 17:39
  • Do you care when many times something intersected? If you only care that it intersected at least twice, you could check the count value in every indented for in where for n,item2 in enumerate(spoof):, then break out of the loop if the count >= 2, rather than continuing to check every shape
    – saph_top
    Apr 11 '19 at 20:51
  • Select a small number of polys that demonstrate the issue (incorrect results with 0 and correct with 1), export selected to new shapefile (delete all uneeded fields) and convert to geojson (i.e. with mapshaper.org) and include (formatted as code) in your question.
    – user2856
    Apr 11 '19 at 21:22

The solution ended up being to change the if-statement to:

   if 1:
      for k,item in enumerate(result):
         for x in touch:
            if x.contains(item.centroid):
         if len(inside)>=2:

The reason for the original error was that the tree.query(<>) only returns the polygons that are likely to interact with the query <> object based on the bounds (top, bottom, left, right) of the objects inside of the tree. The solution was to check whether or not the centroid of the polygon was contained within each member of the list generated by the query. In some cases, the objects returned by the query were in the vicinity of the query object but did not in fact contain it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.