1

Problem as shown in the image: enter image description here I like to correct the GPS track (orange) to the right road (black). In a network of roads it is difficult to snap to the right path - for human it's obvious which one is the right - how can we compute?

Until now i tried to find a solution in QGIS: A. in QGIS 1. buffer road 2. clip track 3. extract vertices 4. snap to road 5. points to path 6. snap to road -> corners ar often cropped

I also tried to smooth the line before. The problems remain...

B. in QGIS: 1. buffer road 2. clip track 3. extract vertices 4. snap to road 5. points to path 6. select by location (intersecting elements of road) -> results with gaps

C. GRASS in QGIS v.edit -> problems of snapping not to the right road perists

D. in POSTGIS: 1. split track in segments of 10m (roads are mostly segments of 10m) 2. calculate Hausdorff distance:

CREATE TABLE tracks2 AS
SELECT  a.id, a.geom
FROM roads a, track1 b 
WHERE ST_HausdorffDistance(a.geom, b.geom)< 3;

-> to many wrong segments, to many missing segments

E. in POSTGIS: I was thinking of a solution with the change of azimuth between points, but I got troubles with the points between the locations of change and corners. (see my previous question: PostGIS: ST_Azimuth between Points in same Table)

And now I found this: Matching segments of different lengths Can someone help mo to implement this in POSTGIS?

Or is there a completely different approach (Python, ...) I also researched the topics map matching / conflation without finding a solution that suits my problem and my possibilities.

  • 2
    this is a heuristic problem under the topic 'map matching' and requires a complex algorithm (e.g. using hidden markov models and viterbi backtracking) to approximate a best fit on a fully modeled network. consider using sophisticated routing machines like OSRM (easily applicable via Node.js bindings) or Graphopper (on Java). – ThingumaBob Aug 21 at 9:51
0

As aicun said, it's a very complicated problem that require a specific implementation (OSRM, Graphopper, ...). You can also find API (like mapbox) that do that without needing to run the application. I think there is also a QGIS extension to that (I found Offline-MapMatching, maybe there is others)

If you want to stay in Postgis and azimuth maybe look into pg-routing, like they tried here: projecting-gps-point-to-point-in-closest-pgrouting-road-map-matching

It's not like a true map-matching, but maybe that can be enough for you. But to be honest, specialized API are way more, in the middle/long term, time efficient. Because if you want to handle it yourself, even with a simplest logic, there is like a LOT of special cases to handle, especially if you use road data for exemple from OSM where the data you need (oneway, no entry) can be in a lot of different fields / relations).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.