I simply want to get a specific attribute (f.e. as label or default value in form) of a feature within another feature. Aggregate could do the job but it don't.

Hard for me to write it down, so let me explain on the screenshot below: All polygons are in the same layer. The green polygon is labeled with the expression:

aggregate('SameLayer','concatenate', to_string("Number"), intersects($geometry, geometry(@parent)))

That works fine so it tells me, I'm on the right way! All intersection features (101, 102, 103) are written to the label (or later to the attribute form). Since I just want the number of the the polygon, where the green one complete fits within, I changed 'intersects' to 'within' (or 'contains') and expect as result: 102 - but it don't!

aggregate('SameLayer','concatenate', to_string("Number"), within($geometry, geometry(@parent)))

The reason is, the green polygon touches with 3 of its sides, the parent polygon. If I draw the polygon complete within the parent, the expression works.

I wonder what could be the right geometry function in my case, and if Aggregate is the right way to solve that trivial task?

enter image description here


I don't know if something is off with how aggregate() handles geometric predicates (I am using QGIS 3.12.2)

I tried using the DE-9!M representation - according to relate() the relationship between the green polygon and 102 was '2FF11F212', so I used that to test the relationship instead of within(), but it kept returning an empty string (or NULL since the green polygon itself has a null value for Number).

Eventually I got it to work with aggregate('SameLayer','concatenate', to_string("Number"), relate($geometry,geometry(@parent),'212F11FF2'))

But, perhaps a crucial difference is that I also managed to get the expression to work with contains(), so maybe our geometries are not the same?? See if the above works for you...

enter image description here

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.