2

I am working on a project aiming to create a geographic simulation for how people interact around a site.

Situation: There are x people in an enclosed area (such as a zoo). There are y locations to visit (attractions).

Scenarios: I want to simulate how busy each location would get with the following decision-making approaches:

  • When no location set, person goes to the next closest unvisited location
  • When no location set, person goes to random unvisited location
  • When no location set, person goes to recommended location (from app, interactive sign, etc)

Outcome: I want to know what leads to the best overall situation. In my case, I want to reduce overcrowding.

Is there any open source software, approaches I should consider for modeling this? I would prefer to do this in Python, though am open to any other options.

3

What you're talking about is agent-based modeling. ESRI has an entire extension for this which is open-source, but of course the ArcGIS platform it runs on isn't.

1

In addition to the aforementioned tools, agentscript is an interesting-looking library I just came across. It's written in CoffeeScript/JavaScript so it can run in a browser, on a node.js server, etc.

Wikipedia also has a Comparison of agent-based modeling software article.

1

Idrisi is very capable of this, it is less expensive than Arc stuff. You can even use python.

If you are just using python, perhaps a basic distance assigned to each site can be added to the data frame and used for the proximity value in Tobler's law.

I think using the spatial application of Tobler's law, where likelihood of visiting a site based on proximity would be an n over distance squared equation, would be a good start. Then, one could add parameters to the Tobler's law equation to represent the different situations presented. I don't know if you have the math already figured out but a coefficient for proximity, effectiveness of recommendations (maybe start with one - a perfect recommendation always adhered to) and a certain crowding factor where if location has more than n people it is not likely to get more.

  • Thanks for this! I'm actually a student so can use ArcGIS for free. Would you suggest using this if we have access to it? – Ollie May 3 '14 at 1:15
  • Absolutely. if you are working in the GIS lab talk to the TA or Prof about adding the extension... if you have a computer that is fast enough ask about a one year trial disk! – c0ba1t May 3 '14 at 14:15
  • TOBLERS LAW! I am sorry, not Moore. – c0ba1t May 8 '14 at 20:22
  • Tobler's makes more sense! – Ollie May 9 '14 at 0:22
  • right?! sorry about that.... anyway, I hope this works out for you. Good luck in your Geospatial Endeavors! – c0ba1t May 9 '14 at 0:46

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.