1

I have a number of vector layers with all types of geometry (point, line/multiline, poly) and I want to combine them into a single layer in QGIS. I know MapInfo can do it but with the other 99% of my workflow in QGIS it's the last step to having a complete pipeline.

It seems there are a number of tools to merge shapefiles together (assuming equivalent geometry types) in QGIS but this doesn't help me. There's ogr2ogr but running the following statement gives me a failure:

ogr2ogr -f "MapInfo File" merge.tab points.tab
ogr2ogr -update -append merge.tab lines.tab -f "MapInfo File"
FAILURE:
Unable to open existing output datasource 'merge.tab'

It'd be fine if I wanted to merge a bunch of layers with the same geometry (use SHP, merge, save result as TAB), but multiple geometry types are eluding me.

I could write a little program using Tatuk Developer Kernel but I'm not that happy with its handling of projections (using EPSG:28355 it seems to create a projection that is 'custom' when viewed in QGIS or MapInfo).

2

OGR cannot update an existing TAB (or MIF/MID) file. It can read and can create, but not update. From http://www.gdal.org/ogr/drv_mitab.html:

MapInfo TAB and MIF/MID

MapInfo datasets in native (TAB) format and in interchange (MIF/MID) format are supported for reading and writing. Update of existing files is not currently supported.

As a workaround, consider converting to some intermediate format, doing the merge / update there, and then exporting to TAB at the end if you have to use that format.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.